A critical review is a description and evaluation of a source, usually a journal article or book. It goes beyond a summary to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the source and to comment on the quality of the source as a whole. Don't let the term "critical" confuse you: it doesn't mean you only look at the negative, which you should do. This assignment consists of several parts and is designed to help you understand how to read, summarize, and critically evaluate journal articles: revise a journal article based on the questions asked: a written summary, critical evaluation, and synthesis of three journal articles.Pengertian Critical Review. The critical review adalah suatu tinjauan kritis and analysis mendalam terhadap suatu karya atau tulisan. Tujuan utama dari review critique adalah untuk: 1. Mengidentifikasi Tujuan Karya: Memahami apa yang ingin dicapai oleh pengarang melalui karyanya. 2.A critical review is an academic evaluation of an article that provides both a summary and critical commentary. They are useful for evaluating the relevance of a source to your academic needs. They demonstrate that you have understood the text and can analyze the main arguments or conclusions. It's not just a summary, it's a.